Friday, November 13, 2026

Dropzone Commander 3.0 the after-game review

So we have just come back from a bootcamp weekend to start off with Dropzone Commander 3. And the short version is that "Dropzone commander is back, baby!". 

Though there are odd things. 



What we did

Over the weekend we had 6 players duking it out on two tables, starting off with starter-demo and then mixing 1000 and 1500pts and with or without command cards. We tried a multitude of missions but tried to keep ourselves to fairly standard things in the missions. We drank and ate well and finished the Saturday with a degenerative barbecue with rough pieces of entrecote in cheap sauce that each person flambeerd on a pointy stick. Good times.      

Overall the sensation and experience is of course as newbies in DZC 3 but we are all experienced miniature gamers with 25+ years of experience each. And the experience was generally a positive one. 

The good

The game is of course gorgeous. 


My autumn table. Got two though I only used one here. 

The second table is a bit dark and my initial handywork was quite the disappointment. But it has grown on me and gives quite a lot of variation to the paper terrain

Need to speak out to the food and the whole set-up over the weekend. It was much easier than normal to get the boys together for a weekend event in the cabin. So everybody was hoping for DZC 3.0 a lot. But while we have alcohol, chips, degenerative barbeque we also eat fairly well. 

Yeah. That happened. 



For the Saturday we had pork side in oven with skin side up and rest under water to give the top a satisfying crispy side. Together with boiled potatos, a creamy brown sauce with panned onions. With that we also had a plate of citrus-sprinkeld sallad with green onion, mild chilli, bellpepper (or whatever Parprika is in non-swedish) with some sambic to give a chocolate sensation on it all. And Coriander. 

For lunch we had hamburgers from the grill with the meat coming from the local farmer. Nice burgers though no pictures. 

For lunch day 2 we had chanterelle soup with salad, garlic bread and a nice salad on the side. 

Perhaps a little over the top describing the food here but while really nothing special it do keep the cost down. Besides alcohol of ones choice I fixed all the soft drinks and food and we came away at about 40 USD per person for everything edible. By Swedish standard that is very cheap. It makes the weekend cheap while still having something sensible to eat, something good to drink, keeping sober if that is one's choice and also have lots of things not so good for you. 

Back to the game, we all had mostly chosen units that play on DZC's main strength: Units inside transports. 


The game looks even better when almost all is magnetized. It is a sad fact we have units in the game not able to be placed seated in transports and I think they really should redesign those units. 

Anyway. For the good. Basically the game flows well. We weren't missing battlegroups that much and any loss or win in our games could be traced to decisions and not die. Just like V1. Most rules work as intended and we had lots of fun. 

It is not really much more to write about on the positive side. We like the game and will continue to play. So that the next part might be larger shouldn't be considered a failure of the game. It is just easier to write negative criticism instead.  

The bad

For me the game has some flaws that boils down to:
1. Markers everywhere. Lots of things to keep track of. 
2. Command cards are way to many and large.
3. Command points are... a bit much. 
4. I miss infantry being more important in the game. But others liked it this way in the group. 
5. There are a lot of special rules and the inflation in the game's power creep from V1 is insane. Games workshop look at DZC and think "no way we could do THAT much power creep!"
6. Unnecessarily complex things (and nit-picking)

1. Markers. 

We found there are a lot of things to keep track of. Which transport belongs to which group. Turn (of course). Command cards. Command points. Shaltari even had a situation where the player needed to keep track of if any gate have disembarked units once or twice. Which scoring turn it is. Damage on buildings and any mission special token. And pass tokens. 

It adds up. We had a lot in V1. To many, one could argue. And now we have a lot more. For the group activation I will try to make any army-list-programmer-creator to make printible unit cards so we can have cards instead of tokens on activated units. It worked well in DZC 1 but now with alternate activation of groups it is much more work to keep track.

The missions, while flexible, adds some markers as well and sometimes bogged it down. 

And many mistakes were made, even when fresh in the head and having plenty of time. There were mistakes in V1 as well. But the expectation from me is that it will be much more now. It is just to easy to forget to activate or miss any transport's activation. And at the same time keep track on the opponent so they don't make mistakes. 

I would have preferred that markers are toned down and removed when possible. And there are ways to do that. Make all weapons in buildings (from cards or from mission) the same. It is ok to tone them down and make them more flexible but I would have preferred a "gun marker" and make it alt 2 (anti tank and AA) and slightly weaker instead of 6 different gun tokens, 8 effect features and 5 indestructible features). I will touch on this several times. The idea of being flexible when making missions is really sound. But it is to many. You can have very similar effect in the game by removing several of them because many of them will not be used other than a odd game once in a while. 

2. Command cards way to many

Originally I thought the command cards were a bit to many. Now I'm certain of it. And building a deck is way to much to add to the game. And time consuming. It should be a smaller deck and the command points to boost/use cards could be removed as well. It would be enough to allow players take a look at the top 2 cards and decide to put them at the bottom or keep at the top. 

At the same time I think there are bit to many different cards as well. It is not needed and I think it would have been better to have fewer cards instead of some with very similar ideas. This can be a mute complaint though as you might just think of the cards as fairly similar and have no issue with them. But I think TT could have gotten away with fewer cards when there are a few that are pretty similar. For instance, there are 3 CQB cards in the general deck. Slightly different. I don't think we would have felt the game to be much more different if all of them was "one enemy squad reroll 5 successful DF die this CQB". It also speeds the game up. Now you have to in detail remember that one card is used only when outnumbered, one is when you are the occupier and one if more flexible. Thus when deciding to keep or remove a card from your hand or deck these things slows things down.    

3. Command points 

I don't play Dropfleet Commander. But I understand the general idea to make the games similar. But I think Command Points are not working so well. A better solution would have been to use the cards for changing transport and checking extra cards in the deck. And even pass token. Taking a look at other games they tend to be restricted a bit in how many complex things making them special. It is enough to keep track of command points in Epic Warpath and here we then have the cards as well. 

While I initially thought that Command Points were a cool idea (it still is), it adds quite a lot without actually adding anything that couldn't be made with cards. 

Changing transport - card. 
Pass token - card
Boosting the strngth of the card - while cool isn't really adding anything - just make the cards balanced as a deck instead. Heck you could use boost with the cards by just discarding another card as a booster as well. 
Checking cards at the deck - Not really needed if a player can discard one drawn card per turn and take another one. 

So having a slighter different set-up would mean that Command Points could be completely removed and the idea of what it is supposed to do could be incorporated into the cards. 

And it is another thing to keep track of. I'm a wargamer since I was 13 so... 8 years now (really 32 years but we go with the maturity level my wife says I'm at) and the question "What turn was it again?" comes up surprisingly often. And then we add which units have activated, which identical transport is with which, command points, pass tokens and more. A lot.  

4. Infantry importance 

In the new Mission the infantry can't hold points. They can hold Zones and interact with objectives. But I kind of miss the missions where the infantry are the key and the rest of the army is there to make sure the infantry get the job done. In DZC they made sure that we had missions where infantry in Zones was worth tripple points in these type of missions. 

The problem is that we get no pure mission in the rulebook (except just killing) like in V1. I would have loved a original Target's of Opportunities. At the same time this wasn't a sentiment that my friends agreed with so it comes down to a fact that in DZC 3 the missions you can create varies greatly. By the very nature it is written you are encouraged to write your own missions. And the variation available from the rulebook is massive. 

But we did have a some situations where the Ground Vehicle situation was so clear there was no point in finishing the game. The only reason we had games finishing to conclusion were the infantry-missions. And I think infantry in Zones is a great way to tackle good vehicles in the game. But by Infantry being pointless if not objectives it removes a big part of the balance. TT have tried with the missions to add guns to buildings in some missions to give infantry something to do and you do have a situation that when infantry does not have anything specific to do they can site the walls and fire out which was something DZC 1 struggled with. 

But I miss infantry not being able to hold points (only for vehicles now) but we can make our own missions and the sentiment was not agreed with in my gaming group. So maybe I'll change my mind later on. 

5. Inflation. 

My god this game has had a Games-workshop-inspired inflation in special rules and power creep! We see Caimans being over the top (already one of the best tanks before), heavy Scourge vehicles getting DP3, the Hades ignoring critical hits and double the amount of damage removed? Basic units have decreased in points because the new units and the inflation made them redundant. 

It all is a natural development. New units makes stupid high damage to make sure people consider them, then we need to increase the power of the old units to counter and all that. I get it. 

But it is not needed. A special rule should be added when needed. Not as a base. I get there is a problem for a Miniature Game Company that they need to sell new stuff and that new units need to add something or be better (or both). But it is really bad for the game in the long term. 

An example: Jaguar
V1. A good solid units often utilized. 110pts. 
V3. -1Mv, Can crit with the Gauss cannons (technically the same as V1). +6" range on the main cannons, Can move and fire 5" on a road. AA gun hits o 2+ instead of 3+. For -15 points.  
   
It is hard to remove advantages though. But I think the Jaguar needed to be improved because the inflation on other units. But my preferred solution would have been making the other units weaker. We clearly saw this during the weekend that some games had no point to finish to conclusion. The power levels increase was obvious. 

6. A thought about Complexity

One thing we found was that there are a lot of things that are close to each other but not quite. A good example with infantry

Agile - pass X Defence rolls automatically
Bloodthirsty -2 to search and may not exit
Breachers - do not require an entrance. When entering a building they make X automatic hits on a enemy infantry squad
Demo charge - basically explosive. 
Dogs - +1 to search and sucks hits. 
FS - strike before normal
Hardy - better DF save. 
Lethal -CQB dice hits automatically
Passive save - even better than hardy
Strong - enemy gets lower DF. 
Terror - -1 to morale and -1 to search. 

My point basically being. That is a lot of rules. And several should be possible to remove, incorporate into the stats or change to reduce in numbers. It comes from one new unit getting a unique special rule that then is incorporated as a general special rule. And in some cases the description of a existing rule isn't giving the same sensation. The problem with this is that many game developers doesn't use this to remove rules but instead add more. And most likely will new units add even more variations of these rules.   

Another good example is Pen X (automatic damage when rolling to damage) and Destroyer X (automatical critical damage). The rules themselves are most likely something that if only one would have existed no one would have cared much. But at the same time we most likely see Devestator, Stealth, Resilient and more comes out because of inflation to counter the first rules. If that unit has X then that unit should get Y to counter but then the first unit need X+Z and so on. 

I'm not saying that there are to many special rules but designing a game should really consider if a rule has to be there.  

All in all I think game designers often make the mistake of thinking that how the models look doesn't affect the experience of how a rule work. Or how a army feel. An example:

Having a Shaltari army with skimmers or walkers could potential have the exact same units with only the skimmer bonus and speed Vs higher armor as a difference. It is enough to give the army flavor. Because they look very different and when we play we imagine them different as well. But designers tend to give them special weapons and larger differences. Original DZC was very good at this. 

UCM: Tank, heavy tank, scout tank.  
Scourge: Fast Skimmer tank.  Heavy tank. Scout walkers. 
PHR: Walker, Heavy walker, Scout walker.
Shaltari: Slow skimmer tank but range, heavier walker, scout skimmer. 

Of course designers want new units want to break this up but the original premise is a strong one. 

Or I'm just afraid of change. I remember doing a battle report when the Ferrum arrived. A hard-to-kill homebase that spawned out 15" movement 6" range strong AT and AA as well as scout. For the cost of 16 Scourge Minders (that could move and fire 4", couldn't attack ground targets and didn't respawn)? Just stupid. It basically killed the original idea of DZC of making units more focused. Flexibility became a norm that we see today and this is one of the reasons basic units need to be cheaper. And heavy units have to be heavier.     

I think several special rules could have been removed. And several rules makes units basically the same but different special rules. The special rules shouldn't be the defining aspect of a unit's existence. The appearance is much more important in a miniature game and that the unit does what one generally expect. 

Big section of complaints. I know. Generally we liked the game and I really think it will be a mainstay in the group and we might even see tournaments and such. I love it is back but there are some things making the game a bit more complex than needed. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Dropzone Commander 3.0 the after-game review

So we have just come back from a bootcamp weekend to start off with Dropzone Commander 3. And the short version is that "Dropzone comma...